EveTushnet.com |
|
|
Conservatism reborn in twisted sisterhood
Archives
February 02 March 02 April 02 May 02 June 02 July 02 August 02 September 02 October 02 November 02 December 02 January 03 February 03 March 03 April 03 May 03 June 03 July 03 August 03 September 03 October 03 November 03 December 03 January 04 February 04 March 04 April 04 May 04 June 04 July 04 August 04 September 04 October 04 November 04 December 04 January 05 February 05 March 05 April 05 May 05 June 05 July 05 August 05 September 05 October 05 November 05 December 05 January 06 February 06 March 06 April 06 May 06 June 06 July 06 August 06 September 06 October 06 November 06 December 06 January 07 February 07 March 07 April 07 May 07 June 07 July 07 August 07 September 07 October 07 November 07 December 07 January 08 February 08 March 08 April 08 May 08 E-mail Me! Note: All emails will be considered for publication, with name attached, unless you request otherwise Other Eve Sites Eve's Published Journalism and Fiction Questions for Objectivists Against Therapeutic Cloning (Part I) Love in the Time of Cloning (Part II) Nietzsche vs. Eros Non-Blogs Shamed Dogan for Missouri State Rep Torture FOIA Capitol Hill Pregnancy Center Arts & Letters Daily City Journal Dappled Things Doublethink Godspy Institute for Justice National Catholic Register Pregnancy Centers Thunderstruck Yale Free Press Daily Stops Amy Welborn Hit and Run MarriageDebate The Corner Unqualified Offerings Sicut cervus: Resources on God and homosexuality Dreadnought discussion boards "Gay sex or Jew. How come Jew won?" The Long Conversion of Oscar Wilde Gay marriage in the Church and the blessing of same-sex friendships (a response to John Boswell, but interesting in its own right) John Heard on Augustine and love between men Ron Belgau autobiographical essay Belgau "Love That Does Not Count the Cost" "Not Exactly Natural (Stunning, Nonetheless)" (me) sequel (me) gay sublime (me) Some stars from a constellation that hasn't been drawn yet (me) In which I attend an ex-gay conference (scroll down for lots of stuff, then up for reactions) Homosexuality & the Church: Two views (mine is view #2) Courage US Catholic bishops to parents of gay children Why you should ignore Paul Cameron Some Iraqi Blogs Iraqi LGBT UK Konfused Kid LivesStrong Inside Iraq Salam Pax 24 Steps to Liberty Iraq Blog Count More Good Reads Abhay Khosla About Last Night After Abortion Agenda Bender The Agitator Alias Clio Balkinization Cacciaguida Child of Divorce - Child of God Christian Persecution Church of the Masses Cigarettes Claw of the Conciliator Club for Growth Colby Cosh Daniel Mitsui Dark October 618 Disputations Disputed Mutability Dreadnought ePiscoSours E-Pression First Things For Keats' Sake Get Religion Holy Heroes Jeremy Lott Journalista KausFiles Kelly Jane Torrance Libertas Mark Shea Marriage Junkie Megan McArdle Millinerd Monster Brains Mumpsimus Noli Irritare Leones Now the Green Blade Riseth O Joyful Light One of the Jones Boys Overlawyered Oxblog Paleo-Future Ross Douthat Scrutinies Sean Collins ShoeBlogs Stop Torture The Rat Virginia Postrel VJ Morton WaiterRant I'm Syndicated! 
|
Wednesday, December 31, 2003
MORE FODDER FOR MY ANTI-SANTA CAMPAIGN. "It is argued that, if children were told the truth, that it would take the joy and magic out of Christmas. I am living proof, however, that this is not true. I was told by my parents that Santa Claus like Superman; he wasn't real, but sometimes it was fun to pretend like he was. My childhood Christmases were as happy as any other, I suspect." "Emmanuel [seminary], it turned out, was unique only in its verdant isolation from the rest of China. Hundreds of other seminaries dotted rural and urban commuities throughout the country. A few weeks later, I visited an underground seminary in a major city in China's southwest. It was one of four apartments being used as seminary colleges. This time, besides having to be in a van with tinted windows, I also had to duck my head down as we drove into the apartment complex. Even Chinese visitors might be closely scrutinized if they were not recognized locals, and too many unanticipated arrivals could trigger a police search at any moment." --Jesus in Beijing Tuesday, December 30, 2003
NEW QUESTION AT MARRIAGEDEBATE.COM: Is marriage a right? Plus lots more from me and people who disagree with me. COMICS ERRATA: Johnny Bacardi writes: Hi, Eve-- Regarding Sleeper, while I can see how it can be interpreted as "being in charge of world events", Tao's organization is more into manipulation of world events for their own benefit, and any superiority achieved is a side effect. The central conflict, to me, is not how Carver can fulfill his mission, but how can he get out of his predicament alive, and does he really think he deserves to, after all he's been a part of and has done. Maybe I'm getting ahead of myself here; if you've only read the first TPB then these things are made a bit clearer. Fave Simpsons quotes: "I've coughed up scarier things than that" --Grandpa Simpson "Kids, you tried your best and you failed miserably. The lesson is, never try." --Homer "My cat's breath smells like cat food" --Ralph Wiggums Happy New Year, Eve! When ya gonna blogroll me? Eve: D'oh! I wasn't clear. I didn't mean that the TAO organization (the thing the main character infiltrates) controls the world. I meant the other organization, with the creepy paradise retreat--the one where TAO kills the father so he can manipulate the son's vote. That one is specifically described as controlling world politics and culture. In re blogrolling, it's all random, but I'll try to update it tonight. T.M.I.? A while ago, I realized that for years I'd been harboring a dark and suppressed anger: I resent dolphins. Seriously. What makes them think they're so smart? They're like all peaceful and junk. They're like the annoying hippies who hold you in contempt because you're not as mellow and One with the Universe as they are, and also you think they should get a job. So you can see that this Onion story would affect me adversely. Just look at the one in the photo. I mean, don't you want to slap that smug smile right off its blue face? Via The Rat--member of a far preferable species. They may spread disease, but at least they're not stuck up. NEW YEAR'S RESOLUTION: I'm going to bite the bullet (mmm, bullet) and see a doctor about my insomnia. Last night just sucked. "You can't keep blaming yourself. Just blame yourself once, and move on." Get many fine Homer Simpson quotes here. "Conscious of the conflict between his desire to be good and his inability to obey his father's advice to bank on his own strength, Richard came to the Christian faith sometime in his senior year. ...His life began to change very quickly. He said even his parents noticed that, while Richard had been something of a wild teenager before going to college, he now seemed compliant and polite." --Jesus in Beijing Not an effect conversion had on me, I'm afraid. Monday, December 29, 2003
"DESIRE: APRIL FOOLS": The fifth and final installment of the current short story. This one was fun. What happens to Holly, the world's first bachelorette adulterer? You can get the final segment here or--I recommend doing it this way--start from the beginning here. Friday, I'll start posting "Getting Fired." READING AROUND IRAQI BLOGS: "usually my nightmares have either Italian girls dumping me, or American soldiers stopping me on check points." Raed of course. Plus, lots of stuff exploding outside the windows, in the night. And black market gasoline. Healing Iraq: "It's good to be back to normal again. By normal I mean total chaos, endless lines for gasoline, long electricity outages, and sounds of unknown explosions and gunfire. Yes you guessed it right, I'm back in Baghdad again. Though to be fair things have relatively improved since the last time. Electricity has been better since Christmas (only 12 hours of outage!) and queue lines at petrol stations are a mile or two shorter. And no I'm not being sarcastic at all. Thats the way it is. "I got back yesterday evening. My parents were really happy and I was surprised to hear that our neighbourhood was surrounded and raided by about a thousand American troops just two days ago. Thank Goodness our house wasn't raided." And much more. Iraq at a Glance: Gas on not-black market. Also, notes from Basra (scroll around). Iraq the Model: "...children who fear the moon." Haunting poem. Also women in Iraq, Uday's Iron Maiden, and electricity. Also a letter from Samoa, Iraq, where the Dutch are at. Mesopotamian: Crocodile tears from the Arab countries. Nabil (of Iraqi sportsblog fame) is back, after his exams. New blogs (new to me, anyway): A Family in Baghdad. Secrets in Baghdad. These are more of Salam Pax's blogchildren. In fact, they are Raed's family. The student has become the master.... Road of a Nation: Blogchild of Iraq the Model. Written by an architectural engineer. Iraq and Iraqis. Expat. Quick and interesting posts. The Iraq Blog Count. This rocks. Iraqi Blog BBS. Via Mesopotamian. Great to see the new "faces." Our prayers are with you and your country. CALIFORNIA LEADS IN MAKING EMPLOYERS PAY FOR JOB DEATHS: ...It happened at the Aguiar-Faria & Sons dairy, a sprawling farm of some 1,700 cows operated by one of Gustine's leading families. Two dairy workers, illegal immigrants from Mexico, drowned in a deep, dark sump hole filled with manure and wastewater. The coroner's report succinctly cataloged their struggles in life and in death: Between them, they had eight pennies and one dime in their pockets; their lungs, however, were packed with bovine excrement. The people of Gustine saw one more hard, cruel stroke of fate. Roy Hubert saw a golden opportunity. In January, in a place where dairy is king, he methodically assembled enough evidence to persuade a grand jury in nearby Merced to indict the farm's general manager and its herdsman for involuntary manslaughter and other felonies. Just like that, both men were looking at nearly five years in prison. ...Many were baffled by what they saw as a ludicrous intrusion by the government. How could there be a crime in something like this, something that nobody ever meant to happen? Especially when Pat Faria had not even been on the farm that day. ...Roy Hubert would have been amazed, and disappointed, by any other response. "These are not evil people," he said. "They are not people who hurt for the sake of hurting. They are not bad people. This is good ol' Pat, good ol' volunteer fireman Pat. He feels terrible. He's devastated. I get a lot of that. Well, good. So are the widow and the mother and the father and sister and brother. Just imagine the incredible despair and anguish as you're drowning in manure." ...California stands alone in the United States in its willingness to prosecute employers who kill or harm their workers by violating safety laws. Long before Congress created the federal Occupational Safety and Health Administration in 1970, California had its own workplace safety standards, and it is one of 21 states that run their own versions of OSHA. Its powerful labor leaders and big-city district attorneys have long been adept at using headline-grabbing workplace deaths to win ever-stronger enforcement powers for the state agency, known as Cal OSHA. Under federal law, it is a misdemeanor to commit safety violations that kill workers. The maximum penalty is six months in jail and a $500,000 fine. But after a deadly refinery explosion in 1999, California adopted one of the nation's first laws making that same offense a felony. In California, conviction carries a sentence of up to three years in prison and a $1.5 million fine. Every workplace death or serious injury in California is investigated with an eye to potential prosecution. That work is done by a special Cal OSHA unit, mostly former police officers, whose members are required by law to refer every death to local prosecutors if there is credible evidence of a deliberate safety violation. Federal law sets a far more exclusive standard: only the most egregious workplace deaths--those caused by an employer's "willful" safety violations--can be referred to the Justice Department. But as The New York Times found in an eight-month examination of workplace death in the United States, in even those worst cases, the federal OSHA only rarely seeks prosecution. It is largely the same story in the other states that run their own workplace safety programs. California has prosecuted more employers for safety violations than all of those states combined, The Times found. At the same time, its workplace death rate is substantially lower than that of the rest of the nation. [Eve's emphasis] Still, California's record can be misleading. Most of these prosecutions take place in Los Angeles, San Francisco and a handful of other large cities whose district attorneys have the resources and political will. In dozens of small rural counties, district attorneys have been just as reluctant as the rest of the country to pursue what are often technical, time-consuming and politically sensitive prosecutions. Roy Hubert and his small band of roving prosecutors are trying to rectify this pattern of uneven enforcement. Called the Circuit Prosecutor Project, they work from the offices of the California District Attorneys Association in Sacramento, under the direction of Gale Filter, a man who combines a prosecutor's cold-eyed pragmatism with a reformer's messianic zeal. ...On dairy farms across the valley floor, there has been a broad reassessment of safety. Farmers are hiring safety consultants, putting their workers through safety training, installing first aid kits and posting signs. "It makes you concerned because you think, 'Heck, he's a dairyman and I'm a dairyman, too,' " said Mark Ahlem, a young farmer in the valley. more Via Amptoons and Confined Space. WEARING BUT A PAPER DRESS: Comics reviews. In alphabetical order to maximize randomness. JM DeMatteis and Glenn Barr, Brooklyn Dreams. This is a fun and easy to read coming-of-age/family/drugs/search for God tale, but nothing more. DeMatteis has a sweet sense of humor, and the drawings are appealingly exaggerated--portraying the world the way children see it, cartoonishly. The pictures set in the past are stark black-and-white, funny, and hyper; those set in the present are awash in gray tones, subtler, adrift in the confusion of adulthood. Very nice stuff--captures the cartoony, exaggerated way the world looks to kids, who have not yet learned a sense of scale. Compassionate pictures of the narrator's parents make the clash of child/teen vs. adult perspective more obvious. Lots of moving stuff here, and lots of fun stuff, but I'm not sure it adds up to a whole heck of a lot. BD at first seemed to be made for me. It's got the Jew vibe, the Catholic vibe, the Dostoyevsky vibe. But it keeps promising more than it delivers. (Lots of suspense--"But we don't have time for that right now..."--which goes from intriguing to really funny to shticky.) I do understand that spiritual payoffs are unusually hard to describe (this is where Creature Tech failed too, for example), but honestly, what am I to make of this kind of thing?: "But here I was--glimpsing the place in every passing heart, where so-called good and so-called evil met, where yin and yang balanced." The pictures do not illuminate this statement. So the book starts much stronger than it ends, unfortunately. Brian Bendis, Fortune and Glory: Well, now I know that I can detest a Bendis comic. This is the story of Bendis in Hollywood, as he tries to make a movie out of his (quite good) comic Goldfish. The pictures are nicely cartoony--gooey arms, bug-eyes--but this is the first Bendis comic to bring out my Inner Editor. I found myself growling, "Cut this. This doesn't work. Cut this. Cut this," at the page. Ordinarily, Bendis's repetitions and stuttering dialogue add to the suspense and drama of a scene. But here, since the stakes of the drama were so low (we already knew the movie doesn't get made, and even if we didn't know that, is this really super-exciting?), the dialogue style just felt like padding. Moreover, much of the book is various people praising Bendis. Isn't this... creepy? Don't buy this. But, also, don't take this as representative of Bendis's generally excellent work. Ed Brubaker and Colin Wilson, Point Blank. I got this because it was the predecessor of Sleeper (which see). It's a fun, twisty covert-ops riddle, with a harsh ending--like something written by a more sadistic Chandler. Until the end, I was underimpressed--was not taken by the art, and this is ultimately just very well-done comics noir--but the ending really twists in your gut. A short sharp shock. Won't change your world, but it is worth your time. Ed Brubaker and Sean Phillips, Sleeper: Out in the Cold. This book is much prettier than Point Blank. It's also not as smart. The premise is sweet: The only person who knows which side a deep cover agent is really working for is in a coma. In order to fulfill his purpose and maintain his identity, the agent has to somehow aid the side he's really fighting for; but how can he do that when nobody trusts him? The characterization is also very nicely done. I especially liked the woman who sickens and dies unless she hurts other people. I like anything that challenges the too-common assumption that acting rightly always makes people feel warm and cuddled. The pages are laid out in tightly-controlled squares. Each character is tightly framed, constrained, often placed behind bars or in even more constraining doorways or windowframes; the squares are always hierarchically ordered on the page, mirroring the hierarchy of the criminal organization the sleeper agent has infiltrated. Hardly subtle, but good-looking nonetheless. I note that for whatever reason, the pages of this book also felt heavier or glossier--more fun to turn--than usual. There's a predictable but effective sensual pleasure here. I was seriously annoyed by one major plot element: This comic features a cabal that controls the world. That's stupid. The world is messier than that. These people need to read their Hayek--top-down control will always be worked around; there is no They that tells you what to do and what to like. There are no excuses for our lousy choices. Apparently Sleeper is only getting better, so perhaps this cabal is ultimately revealed as fakery; but within this book it irritated me and made the protagonists look gullible. Nor was it in any way necessary to the plot, at least not so far. Despite these criticisms, I'm pretty sure I'll be on the lookout for more Sleeper. There's always room for slick noir fun. Bruce Baugh reviews both books at greater length, and tells you more about the plot than I did (but not in a spoilery way). Christophe Blain, The Speed Abater. I bought this as part of the ongoing ghost-ship project. It's the story of a sailor in the French Navy and his misadventures aboard an aging ship. It is all right. The story takes a while to get off the ground, and really only startles and captures when the sailors descend into the mechanical hell that drives the ship. But the scenes amid the heat and noise of the machinery are vivid and powerful. Worth checking out if ships are your thing; otherwise probably not so much. I will say that Blain writes good argument scenes, which I respect since it's something I find difficult. "SLEEP? THAT'S WHERE I'M A VIKING!" Contribute your favorite "Simpsons" lines. Yes, it's one of those threads. I love those threads. "Even Gore Vidal has kissed more boys than me!" "Girls, Lisa. Boys kiss girls." I'm afraid of people who like Blogwatch in the Rye; Yeah, I like it too, But someone tell me why... (Actually I really hated Catcher in the Rye the only time I read it, but maybe that's because my school made us read it in, I think, junior high. This cannot be the best way to read the book.) Daniel Drezner: American tariffs and subsidies throw American candymakers out of work. Interesting stuff in comments, too. Oxblog explains why this post is important: It's easier to see the concentrated costs of free trade than the diffused benefits. More Drezner can be found at AndrewSullivan.com, where DD is guest-blogging. Hit & Run: Families Against Mandatory Minimums on TV! Yay! Kesher Talk: Big list of Jewblogs. (BlogJews?) Rabbis, rebels, Reformers, and assorted whatnot. Krubner: "This is a project that I've been meaning to get to for over a year: going over the work of Christopher Hill on this weblog, and in particular his book The World Turned Upside Down. For the next 2 weeks, with a few exceptions, posts will be about the English Revolution of the 1640s and 50s and also, in particular, the clash that arose between what might be called 'bourgeois' Protestantism, and the much more radical kind of Protestantism that flourished during the revolution. "Rarely has any nation gone through as much spiritual turmoil as England did from 1646 to 1653. It interests me that things like atheism can become a mass event, like a mass hysteria, enveloping large chunks of the public for a year or two, before the mood passes. "It interests me more that much of a nation might suddenly realize that they can be saved, that Jesus, perhaps, died for them. ..." Punishment Theory: Very interesting debate thread about "faith-based prisons." Via Los Volokh. GoogleAlert: Tells you when something new comes up when someone Googles your name. Indirectly via the Invisible Adjunct. The PoMo English Title Generator. Instant hilarity. "Among Chinese Christians themselves is the belief--indeed some Chinese Christians refer to it as a divine calling--for Christian believers from China to bring the Gospel to the Muslim world." --David Aikman, Jesus in Beijing: How Christianity Is Transforming China and Changing the Global Balance of Power Friday, December 26, 2003
LYRICS TO "OBEDIENCE SCHOOL": I've been listening to this Brian Dewan song (listen to it here) obsessively for the past, oh, week or so. The lyrics don't seem to be online anywhere. This is what I gleaned: When I was in obedience school, I could make a rabbit stew. I could fix a sewage pipe, I could build a beaver dam. When I moved to a rooming house, No one told me what to do. Now I play with bottlecaps; I can break a drinking glass. People tell me every day, "Don't tell people what to do!" Well, that's all right--I'll do it like you tell me to. Everybody is in charge, Cooks aplenty making broth for everyone, Bumping into everyone. But back when I was in obedience school, I could fold a paper plane. I could wear a pilgrim hat, I could [make?] a dinner [???]; Sit beside a metronome, Listen to an intercom, File into a corridor, Be made to do a jumping jack; Sing a song of loyalty Wearing but a paper dress; Standing in the morning rain, Sing a song all o'er again; Spend the afternoon indoors Making useful things from trash, Learn to build a candy dish, Eat a can of tuna fish, Scour and scrub a basement sink, Sweep around a skating rink. Oh, those bygone days! They were so peaceful and great. MEA CUBA: Powerful meditation on Spain, Cuba, family, and Sister Death. Your dose of myrrh at Christmastide. Must-read. Via Dappled Things. PARTS OF A HOLE: Dappled Things' sermon for Christmas. Describing that feeling of insufficiency, of thirst in a salt sea, that is one of the greatest motive forces in history. ...The problem seen by the Jews and pagans is not a long-gone problem of the distant past. As long as humanity exists, there will also exist the problem of the emptiness of the human heart. What can possibly fill it? It is a problem that confronts us all. ...From the poorest peasant to the Queen upon her throne, everyone, when he sits alone and thinks about his life and ponders his place in the world, realizes that his existence is a very fragile thing and that his little joys are easily lost in an ocean of solitude and shadows. In these moments of introspection, he sees that he himself shares the problem of the ancients, that he himself can feel that same empty hole within his own heart, and this emptiness smells of death. The meaning of Christmas is that God has understood all of this and has come into the midst of our existence -- not as some abstract presence hovering up above us all, not as some ethical rules that will produce a happier life, not as a few pretty thoughts and swollen words -- He has come in flesh and bone, this same flesh and bone that you and I share. He knows our condition because He has lived it Himself. This is Christmas. This Child that lies today upon the manger of wood, one day upon a Cross of wood will die. He was born for us, and for us He will be sacrificed. more CS Lewis comments on same SING HO! FOR THE BIBLICAL GENEALOGIES!: Mark Shea has an excellent post on, as he puts it, "Why the Biblical genealogies aren't boring." "I now know that if you describe things as better than they are, you are considered to be romantic; if you describe things as worse than they are, you will be called a realist; and if you describe things exactly as they are, you will be thought of as a satirist." --The Naked Civil Servant Tuesday, December 23, 2003
HEY, MY REGISTER COLUMN ON THE MASSACHUSETTS SSM DECISION IS ONLINE! I didn't know that. (I note they declined to use my draft headline, "From the State That Brought You Harvard.") It's not every day a court gets to stand against all of recorded history. That's what the Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court did Nov. 18 when, in Goodridge v. Department of Health, it ruled that marriage in Massachusetts is no longer the union of a man and a woman but the union of "two persons." The court argued that forbidding a man to marry another man constituted unlawful and irrational sex discrimination. ...The Massachusetts court is saying to citizens, "You all go ahead and vote for the laws. Then we'll tell you what you really voted for. Don't expect it to look much like what you thought you agreed to." The rule of law requires that laws be predictable and stable--that laws not be yanked out from under citizens like a carpet in a Tom and Jerry cartoon. The Massachusetts court (like the Supreme Court in Roe v. Wade) has ignored this principle. The funny thing is, this bait-and-switch approach to judging may be turned against the Goodridge decision itself in the future. ...Marriage--civil marriage, not just sacramental marriage--is essentially a procreative union in two ways. more HITS AND MISSES 2003: Stuff I wrote on this blog in the old year. Some of my archives are Bloggered, so this is incomplete; shrug. January: Tradition vs. the past: "...The first and most basic point is that tradition is not about restoring some real or imagined past era. Tradition gives an institution (a nation, a debating society, a university) a persona; it makes the institution more like a person. And this is necessary in order to make the institution a possible object of human loyalties, since all our loyalties are to persons. ... "I've also found that tradition's roots are often very odd--and that isn't a point against tradition! Tradition often develops and accumulates in a Hayekish spontaneous-order kind of way, but along the way traditions also result from jokes, accidents, and misreadings...." In defense of free will: "First, a recent conversation with my friend Gene underlined for me the ways in which the question of freedom of the will is linked to the question of personal identity. Free will requires that there be a 'me' who chooses, rather than simply a pushing and pulling jostle of neural impulses and affects. ... "...I tend to believe that free will is one of the philosophical questions that is far better handled in poetry and fiction than in philosophy, in part because it is such a bedrock, foundational issue...." March: Against torture. Why was this controversial? Anyway, start here and scroll down as desired. "Better to die like a man than to live like a utilitarian." May: Two Spenserian stanzas I wrote: "Time is regret" and "'I love you when you're less like me!'" And I argue that those who hate Bush v. Gore should also oppose Roe v. Wade. Start here and scroll for my (attempted) rebuttal of Prof. Jack Balkin's theory of "high" vs. "low" politics in Constitutional jurisprudence. And addiction as ritual. June: What my wisdom teeth have to do with abortion and "women's right to know" laws. And a pro-life reading list for people who want to know why I, and many people I know, stopped supporting legal abortion. October: My review of "Carnival of Souls." This is a short piece but I really like it--I do think it gets at the reasons CoS is one of the best horror movies ever. Rene Magritte, Master of Horror. "Belgium is an absence of identity." A round-up link to October's same-sex marriage post series. December: Superfast, allusive descriptions of great comics you might like. Comparisons between media: comics to movies, comics to novels, comics to paintings, whatever. "In the sixties, if you tell someone that you are a practitioner of advertising, you will still be treated as though you had said you were in burglary, but morality has changed. The increased scale of your operations will lend you respectability. Who, except possibly the Postmaster General, would refuse to shake hands with one of the Great Train Robbers?" --The Naked Civil Servant Monday, December 22, 2003
DEATH ON THE JOB: Via Amptoons I find Confined Space, a blog devoted to workplace safety and health. You should go there now for the NYTimes pieces at the top of the page: "A Trench Caves In, A Young Worker Is Dead. Is It a Crime?" and "US Rarely Seeks Charges for Deaths in Workplace." Sad, angering, and gripping stories. A while back, I did a chunk of research and several interviews on various OSHA reform proposals, for a "news analysis" story that never quite jelled. I generally prefer market-based solutions--for reasons including a) market solutions tend to be suppler and better able to respond to changing conditions and practices; and b) governmental, top-down regulatory solutions are often hijacked--is the phrase I'm looking for "regulatory capture"?--as the biggest players write the regulations to favor themselves and disfavor smaller competitors. So I read some libertarian-oriented analyses of OSHA (though I don't think any were dogmatically, or "rigorously" if you prefer, libertarian) and also spoke with various scholars about proposed regulatory tweaks meant to give the governmental structures some of the flexibility of market structures. E.g. attempts to make workplace regulations focus more on outcomes rather than on processes (= "reduce death and injury at your workplace by X amount or X percent by time T--we don't care how you do it, just do it--here's a guide to best practices if you need ideas, but basically, just get your deaths and injuries down"). Many of these sounded like good ideas, but none seemed sufficient. This is an area where I'm not especially libertarian, though I'll note that I'm far from an expert here--not even an "insta-expert" of the faking-it-in-the-service-of-journalism kind. My point (and I do have one) is that, wonk proposals and counterproposals aside, this should change: "[Even companies that willfully violated the law and killed workers] face lighter sanctions than those who deliberately break environmental or financial laws. "For those 2,197 deaths, employers faced $106 million in civil OSHA fines and jail sentences totaling less than 30 years, The Times found. Twenty of those years were from one case, a chicken-plant fire in North Carolina that killed 25 workers in 1991." The sun is a mass of incandescent gas, a gigantic nuclear blogwatch... Charles Murtaugh is back, with much LOTR-ness and biotech-talk--and even two posts that combine both! Oxblog: Ways to fight terror by spending your Christmas money. It's the American way! Unqualified Offerings: Qualifying (ha ha) claims (linked on this very blog, and coming from such notable hawks as the New York Times editorial board) that Libya's announced end to its WMD programs is a consequence of the Iraq war. More on the invasion of Iraq/disarmament of Libya connection, working both sides of the street, from CalPundit. I'll note only that you needn't believe Libya's announcement is a huge shocking about-face to think the invasion of Iraq gave Gaddafi a big push to move faster. Speaking of UO: In case you missed that fine blog's post on why you should be leery of the memo alleging a Saddam/Atta/Nidal terrorists R us link, here's the Newsweek story claiming that the memo is likely a fake. Sorry I forgot to post this earlier. And last... ImplosionWorld, "Where Demolition Comes Alive." Via Mark Shea. Sunday, December 21, 2003
MAKING THE PICTURES BIG: GodSpy interviews Barbara Nicolosi: "...When you've been thrown out of the convent during the worst vocation crisis in the history of the Church, what else can the world do to you? "...If we turned over Hollywood to the Christians tomorrow, we'd make worse movies than we're making now because they would mostly be guilty of what Flannery O'Connor called--for Christian--'inexcusable sentimentality.' "...One of the reasons Barbara Hall became a Catholic, as she expressed it to me, was: 'I just got exhausted with unbelief. I just couldn't keep it up anymore.' She's typical of the creative community that has worn itself out since the sexual revolution, throwing itself around, doing anything it wanted, absolute license and power. And they're exhausted. So, they come to faith with a deep understanding of sin. "...First, in terms of artistry, I think the Catholics, even the ones who are lapsed, have a natural sense of allegory and metaphor that comes from several thousand years of ingrained liturgy. The liturgy is real, but it's also rich in symbols. So you have the people who are fallen away--I'm thinking of a screenwriter right now who's an angry, angry ex-Catholic. He's done so much harm. But he has an instinctive sense of symbolism that gives his writing visual power. I've said to him several times, 'the reason you're really good is because you were Catholic' and when we're alone he'll acknowledge it. I think the liturgical tradition is key to that. "...I think that, unfortunately, a lot of orthodox Catholics and Christians are either sitting in the cave hunkered down, or they're like Jonah sitting under a Gourd plant waiting for God to vent his wrath on the world--on the ungodly--and they're going to be disappointed if He doesn't. I don't see these people having sorrow for sin; I see them having indignation towards sin. And to me, that's an important difference. Sorrow for sin is 'I am a part of this.' Indignation for sin is 'you are the ones messing up the world.'" more I know a girl from a lonely street, Cold as blogwatch, but still as sweet... About Last Night: Terry Teachout quotes the best passage from CS Lewis's best work: "All reality is iconoclastic. The earthly beloved, even in this life, incessantly triumphs over your mere idea of her. And you want her to; you want her with all her resistances, all her faults, all her unexpectedness. That is, in her foursquare and independent reality. And this, not any image or memory, is what we are to love still, after she is dead." Hit and Run: Libya disarms. Dominos going click-click-click? Marriage Movement: "Home is the place where you begin when you ask 'Who am I?' 'Where did I come from?' Having two homes oriented around two separate poles of mom and dad means the child travels between two wholly differentiated spheres of moral and spiritual meaning. The parents do not communicate or seek accord on these core issues anymore, but the child still looks to both of them at the first and most important role models for how to think and what to believe. The child must seek, alone, to make sense of all the differences that he or she observes in the parents and develop his or own identity and value system much more independently than children of intact families -- who live in one home -- must do." Oxblog: Law books to Iraq. NYTimes: Bush was right on Libya. And if I said this, you'd all hate me: "Homosexuals can always tell tinsel from gold, they just prefer the tinsel." Do I get away with it by saying I think there's something intensely attractive and human there? Wednesday, December 17, 2003
If I had a gun For every blog that I have watched I could arm a town the size of Abilene... Church of the Masses: Why artists can't accept aesthetic relativism--a dialogue: "Writer Friend: ...I could go on about what's wrong with anything... but what's the point? "Barb N: Because we want to be great artists." Thought Balloons: These are really pretty covers. Like broken-up Soviet realism. Og like. (Yeah, that really shored up my anti-aesthetic-relativism stance....) A Volokh Conspirator on France's hostile secularism. Relapsed Catholic points out that headscarves are often worn because women fear they'll be attacked without them; I like how thoroughly the French government is avoiding addressing that problem. Bishop Accountability. Tracks news, court documents, etc. related to Catholic clergy abuse. If you check out this site I strongly recommend you also take a look at Amy Welborn's site (which is where I got the link), since she reminds us that while these sites are absolutely necessary, they're necessary as a way of cleansing the Church and returning us to focus on Christ. "'I shall go and tell the indestructible man that someone plans to murder him.'" --Alan Moore, Watchmen Tuesday, December 16, 2003
IRAQNESS: Iranian blog reactions to Saddam's capture. Healing Iraq: "I still haven't been able to get rid of this deep sadness that has overcome me the last two days. People have been emailing asking me to explain. I wish I could, but I simply can't. "...If you had lived all your life ruled by a tough dictator elevated to the level of a god and then suddenly without warning watched that dictator displayed to the public on tv as a 'man', you probably would have related with my position. "The images were shocking. I couldn't make myself believe this was the same Saddam that slaughtered hundreds of thousands and plundered my country's wealth for decades. The humiliation I experienced was not out of nationalistic pride or Islamic notions of superiority or anything like that as some readers suggested. It was out of a feeling of impotence and helplessness. This was just one old disturbed man yet the whole country couldn't dispose of him. We needed a superpower from the other side of the ocean to come here and 'get him' for us. I was really confused that day I went out and almost got myself killed by those Fedayeen and angry teenagers in the Adhamiya district. "...He must be handed over to Iraqis. I don't care about legitimacy. He must be tried publicly in an Iraqi civil court by Iraqi judges. The rest of the Arab dictators should see it and learn from it. "And I'm still wondering why? Why did he have to put himself into this? Why did he have to destroy Iraq? What did he gain from all of this?" Enormous amount of stuff at Iraq the Model and you should read all of it. Including: "I met him in a photo copy office owned by a friend. My friend introduced him to me, his name is Firas Mahmood Ya'koob, a junior resident in Al-Karkh hospital for surgery in Baghdad, a shy young man, holding some photos of men, women, and children. He wanted to make copies of them so I knew there was a story behind them. I couldn't help asking him about it, he said 'I'm from Al-Dujaile.' "I understood what he meant. In Saddam's time we used to whisper about Al-Dujaile, we all knew that a massacre happened there, but we didn't dare to ask about the details and I never met any one from there. Now I can know all about it from my new friend and here it is, in his own words..." more Plus news bites. And this: "I asked one of the waiters about the secret behind this sudden improvement, he laughed and told me: Saddam's gone now, and our boss can expand his business without worrying about being kicked out of this place and losing every thing he spent on this coffee shop, Saddam and his relatives had enormous greed for any piece of land near the river." And more. Where Is Raed is back on the air: "There was another moment when the GC members were describing their meeting with Saddam and told the journalists about the deriding remarks he made when they asked him about the Sadir's assasination and the mass graves, he sounded like he has totally lost it. "I want a fully functioning Saddam who will sit on a chair in front of a TV camera for 10 hours everyday and tells us what exactly happened the last 30 years. I do not care about the fair trial thing Amnesty Int. is worried about and I don'r really care much about the fact that the Iraqi judges might not be fullt qualified, we all know he should rot in hell. but what I do care about is that he gets a public trial because I want to hear all the untold stories" more "DONNIE DARKO": Saw this movie on Friday with Tepper, an anarchocapitalist for marriage, and Mrs. Shamed. (Tepper: "So... we've got a conservative, an anarchocapitalist, and a radical federalist." What better group to see a movie about a giant apocalyptic rabbit?) Anyway. I'm still not sure whether "DD" made any sense. Apparently this site OOPS! this site! offers some guidance. I will say that I am really, really, REALLY looking forward to seeing it again. It feels sprawling or sloppy in structure, but I'm pretty sure every moment was crafted to advance the point--whatever that point was! The main thing I'm still trying to figure out is what the $#@! was up with Jim Cunningham and his final fate, so if you have theories on what happened to him and how it plays into the main questions of the movie, send 'em along. I described "DD" to Ratty as "a perfect late '80s/early '90s teen-rebellion flick--like 'Heathers' or 'Pump Up the Volume' only much better--crossed with a Christian or quasi-Christian apocalyptic movie." Her response: "So basically this was the movie of your life, then?" Yeah. I've gotta see this again. I have only come here seeking knowledge, Things they would not teach me of in blogwatch... [Are those really the lyrics? "Things they would not teach me of in college"??? I thought it was the much-less-stupid "things they would not teach me back in college." Points off, "Sting." ("Sting"?) ("Hannnnsel?"--prize to whoever gets that one.)] After Abortion: More on post-abortion grief--don't try to go it alone; and more on post-abortion depression: "Sarah Stoesz of Planned Parenthood indicated in her letter to the Minneapolis Star-Tribune that '10 percent of women who have abortions experience depressive symptoms of a lingering nature.' "I could have gone on to include her claim, as per her linked letter, that a similar percentage of women who give birth experience lingering depression. "I also could have pointed out that both of her claims are unsupported by current research...." more MarriageMovement: Besides the usual Marquardtly goodness, there's a series of sharp posts from Tom Sylvester on Strom Thurmond and his daughter: "He paid his daughter to deny her own father. For over 60 years. And it was his fault that she would have been poor in the first place." Public image, limited. And Thurmond as illegitimate father. The Volokh Conspiracy: Randy Barnett on the Ninth Circuit decision, based on Commerce Clause, invalidating prohibition of medical marijuana. I don't pretend to understand the commerce clause; on first glance this looks like the right call, and certainly I'm happy about the policy outcome. And it's a beautiful day/For an Otto-da-Fe. "'I want him to go to Hebrew school! I want him to be bar mitzvahed! How can a boy named 'Vinny' be bar mitzvahed?'" --JM DeMatteis, Brooklyn Dreams Monday, December 15, 2003
THE BAD SEX AWARDS. Arguments for censorship. One runner-up includes the term "pant-hoots," which are panting hoots, I think. Don't say I didn't warn you. Via Arts and Letters Daily. FIGHT SOCIALIZED SORCERY! "Evil makes good look better," "AWAKE! to the danger of gawking!", "RESIST PLASTICS," and many other fine slogans. Fun stuff. Tangentially via Motime Like the Present. SURVEY: Found randomly amid various Internet flotsam. 1. Which book are you currently reading? JM DeMatteis/Glenn Barr, Brooklyn Dreams. And Lend Me Your Ears, a collection of speeches edited by William Safire, but you really can't take that on the bus or in the bath, thus it's hard for the Book Ape to make progress here. 2. What book did you read last? The Great Short Works of Franz Kafka, tr. Joachim Neugroschel. "In the Penal Colony" is the best by far. The short-shorts aren't nearly as hard-hitting or skewed as the ones in Parables and Paradoxes, which I need to reread. 3.What book are you planning on reading next? Quimby the Mouse, that speeches book, and Plutarch's Lives if I can find my copy. If I can't find my copy and get too lazy to schlep to the library, I'll probably read The Naked Civil Servant to see how it's (/I've) aged. If I do schlep to the library, I'll probably forget about Plutarch and get sucked into reading The Book Against God. 4. Do you own most of the books you read, or do you borrow them from a library? Half and half except for comics, which you really can't find in the DC library system. 5. Who was your favourite author when you were a child? Diana Wynne Jones for overall achievement; Peter S. Beagle for writing my absolute favorite childhood book, The Last Unicorn. 6. What were some of your favourite books when you were a child? Find them here... plus Diana Wynne Jones and Michael de Larrabeiti. Oh and Helen Cresswell. Good grief, didn't I read any red-blooded Amurricans? 7. Which literary character would you least like to be stranded on a desert island with and why? Hamlet! Talk talk talk! Or, even moreso, the kid from Call It Sleep--I'd feel guilty just looking at that boy. 8. Which character would you most like to be stranded with? Adrian Healey maybe? That could get a bit tense, though. Let's go with Donald Trefusis instead. 9. In which literary/fictional location would you most like to live? Wow, there are just about no books set in the parts of DC I love. Let's go with the pseudo-Savannah depicted in Midnight in the Garden of Good and Evil. 10. Which is the best TV/film adaptation of a book you have seen? why? "The Last Unicorn." Script entirely from book, animation beautiful and perfectly captures both the darker tones and the sweet humor of the book. And I grew up with the Journey songs so I don't mind them. I guess "Lion in Winter" doesn't count because it's originally a play. "Gone With the Wind" is also amazing, though not as good as the book. 11. Which is worst TV/film adaptation of a book you have seen? why? Again, "Titus" probably doesn't count (originally a play). And really, it does an excellent job of mimicking the absurdities of the original. ("Enter Lavinia with her hands cut off, her tongue cut out, and ravished.") 12. What film adaptation do you actually like more than the book? Hmmm... can't think of one off the top of my head. 13. What book do you like better than the film adaptation? Ghost World 14. What is your least favourite book and why? I doubt this is actually my least-favorite book, but I do remember loathing Silas Marner. All that blonde symbolism. I also deeply resented having to read Things Fall Apart not once but twice for class. AFTER ABORTION: Two random thoughts: First, about 80% or so of the post-abortive women I've counseled express serious regrets. I do realize there's self-selection going on here; we're a pro-life center (although many, many of our clients view abortion as a tragic necessity) and most of our clients were raised Christian. But I also wonder whether our attempts to understand "post-abortion grief" aren't stymied by a misunderstanding of a particular kind of Protestantism. Many of my clients have felt regret after abortion that is as deep (as far as I can tell) as any regret they've ever felt. They then confess to Christ, ask for forgiveness, and know that Jesus forgives; and they move on, as they move on from other actions that they know are grave sins. Because all this is private and can happen in a moment (praying the Sinner's Prayer, for example, or responding to an altar call), I think it can look, to people raised outside this particular strain of Protestantism, less weighty and less of a relief of a terrible burden than it really is. These women speak very precisely about how they've dealt with their grief and moved on; but the way they deal with grief and regret over abortion is the way they would deal with grief and regret over any terrible sin. They give it to God and move on. That can be off-putting to people who come to post-abortive women with preconceived notions that they should feel no regret or that they should feel a constant, inconsolable ache. Fortunately, I'd been so thoroughly indoctrinated into abortion-rights propaganda that I was expecting very few of our post-abortive clients to express regret at all, so I was startled enough to pay attention when that turned out not to be true. NOTE: I edited this post because Avram of Pigs and Fishes pointed out that the thing that prompted these thoughts, a link on After Abortion that is actually making a different point, doesn't say what I thought it said--should have been much more careful: "Eve -- "Did you follow the link to the StarTribune article? It says 'Studies show that 10 percent of women who have abortions experience depressive symptoms of a lingering nature. The same symptoms occur in just as many women after childbirth.' The implications are a bit different with that second sentence attached. "According to the National Institute of Mental Health, that's about the same as the percentage of the general adult American population (9.5%) that suffers clinical depression, and lower than the percentage of women in general (12%) that are affected by a depressive disorder each year." I shouldn't've been linking to the Star-Tribune piece anyway, since what I wanted to write about was post-abortion grief and regret (emotional and spiritual categories) rather than depression (medical category). Apologies.... JANUARY 2003 REASON DEBATE ON INVASION OF IRAQ: John Mueller (anti-invasion) vs. Brink Lindsey (pro). Worth a read, now. My take: Mueller misses the point of the North Korea comparison (he assumes Saddam-nukes are only geopolitically dangerous if Saddam makes the incredibly stupid decision to use them, rather than the not-stupid-at-all decision to use them as major leverage at the bargaining table) and somehow forgets that Saddam's sons were possibly more freakazoid than their father. He also conflates two kinds of threats: "One can’t simultaneously maintain that Iraq’s military forces will readily defect and can easily be walked over--a common assumption among our war makers--and also that this same pathetic military presents a serious international threat." I don't think any warmongers were arguing that Saddam's troops were the problem. And he muddies distinctions between kinds of tyrants. Yeah, they're all egomaniacs. But nobody thinks Jean-Bertrand Aristide (or Papa Doc Duvalier!), or Fidel Castro, is trying to develop WMDs. How come? However, he makes good points about the oil market, the terrorism ties, and the difference between international response to the Iran/Iraq war and international response to any future ("future" from the January 2003 perspective of course) Iraqi invasion of Kuwait or elsewhere. Lindsey relies on the belief that Saddam was in the process of developing WMDs, which seems, at this point, either unlikely or a great anti-war argument (= war led to WMDs being shipped out of Iraq to points unknown). Sure OK, pretty much everyone, including anti-war types, thought Saddam was amassing WMDs. Why wouldn't he? Still, this point tells strongly against Lindsey today. Lindsey makes strong points about Saddam's wigfest character and Mueller's blitheness. The debate leaves me as clouded as ever--I tend to think Mueller more persuasive--but it is definitely worth a read. Via Hit & Run. |